Pomade vs Clay vs Paste vs Wax vs Gel: Hair Products Compared

The shelves are full of products with overlapping names and vague marketing copy. In practice the whole category comes down to a few questions: how much hold you need, how much shine you want, whether the product adds grip or smoothness, and how easily it washes out. Once you know where each product sits on those scales, choosing one for your cut and hair type is straightforward. Formulas vary by brand, so treat the ratings below as typical ranges, and read the hold and shine ratings on the tin.

Hair products compared: hold, shine, texture and washability

Clay vs paste vs wax vs gel: the quick difference

• Clay is the matte, volumising option. It absorbs oil and gives hair grip, so it makes fine hair look thicker and holds messy, textured shapes.
• Paste is the softer, more flexible cousin of clay. Similar low-shine finish, less grit, easier to restyle with your fingers during the day.
• Wax is the most pliable. Lighter hold with a little shine, best for defining individual pieces on short hair. It builds up faster than most products.
• Gel is the hardest hold and the wettest shine. It sets like a cast and will not restyle until you wet it again.

Pomade is the other big category: it is the choice when shine and a combed, smooth shape are the goal rather than texture.

Product by product: what you need to know

Pomade (oil-based vs water-based)

Oil-based pomade is made from petrolatum, oils and waxes. It gives a high gloss and never fully sets, so you can re-comb it through the day and it holds its shape without going crunchy. The downside is removal: it does not dissolve in water, so it usually takes a clarifying shampoo or two or three washes to get out, and it can leave pillowcases greasy. It is the traditional product for a hard-part pompadour, a classic slick-back and brushed 360 waves. Water-based pomade uses water and polymers instead. It rinses out with a single shampoo, comes in light to strong holds, and gives a sheen that ranges from subtle to glossy. Stronger formulas dry firmer, so re-wet your comb if you need to restyle. For most people it is the practical everyday choice for the same styles.

Clay

Clay combines mineral clays such as kaolin or bentonite with waxes. The clay absorbs oil from the hair and scalp, which gives strands grip and makes fine hair look fuller. The finish is matte and hold is medium to strong depending on the formula. Apply to completely dry hair: warm a fingertip-to-pea-sized amount between your palms, work it in from the roots and underneath, then shape with your fingers. It is the go-to for the textured crop, a messy quiff, a faux hawk and any style where you want volume without shine.

Paste

Paste sits between clay and wax. It is creamier than clay, with a matte to low-sheen finish and medium hold that stays flexible rather than setting rigid. Run your fingers through it at lunchtime and it redistributes instead of flaking. It suits natural-looking styles: a French crop, a relaxed side part or a short, tousled cut on normal to thick hair.

Wax

Wax is the most workable product: light to medium hold, pliable all day, low to medium shine. Use it for short styles where defining individual pieces matters more than height. It can look greasy on fine hair and builds up with daily use, so use less than you would of any other product and wash it out properly.

Gel

Gel gives the firmest hold and a wet-look shine. Applied to damp hair it dries into a hard cast that will not move until you wet it again. That makes it useful for sleek, fixed shapes, laying down edges and defining curls (the crunchy cast can be scrunched out once dry for soft, defined curls). The common problem is flaking, which happens when too much gel dries on the hair or scalp and breaks when touched. Use less, apply it to the hair rather than the scalp, and do not touch it while it dries.

Cream

Cream is a conditioning product with light hold and a natural, low sheen. Its job is smoothing, taming frizz and giving soft control without stiffness. It is the right choice for longer styles, curtains and middle parts, flows, and wavy, curly or coily hair that needs moisture more than hold. Apply to damp hair for even coverage.

Mousse

Mousse is a lightweight foam that adds lift at the root and light, flexible hold. Work a golf-ball-sized amount through damp hair before blow-drying. It is a good pre-styler for fine or flat hair (follow with a little clay or paste if you need more hold) and for defining curls without the weight of a cream.

Sea-salt spray

Sea-salt spray uses salt to add grip and a slightly rough, beachy texture. Spray onto damp hair, scrunch or blow-dry, and you get body and loose movement that makes the hair easier to style. It works best on straight to wavy hair (roughly types 1B–2C) and as a pre-styler under clay or paste. Salt draws moisture out of the hair, so on dry, curly or coily hair it tends to cause frizz; use a cream or mousse instead.

Which product for which style

How to apply any product correctly

1. Start small. A fingertip to pea-sized amount for short hair. You can add more; you cannot remove excess without washing.
2. Emulsify. Rub the product between your palms until warm and almost invisible. Skipping this is the main reason product looks clumpy or uneven.
3. Work from the back and underneath first. Get product into the roots and underside before touching the front. This builds support at the base instead of coating only the surface, and stops the front getting overloaded.
4. Style with fingers or a comb. Fingers for loose, textured styles (clay, paste, wax). A comb or brush for smooth, structured styles (pomade, gel).
5. Set it. If you blow-dried, finish with the cool shot. If air-drying, avoid touching the hair while it dries.

As an Amazon Associate, Haircut.info earns from qualifying purchases. Prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown.